Billy's eyes widened a bit and he took a step back. Well crap, he'd just put his foot right into his mouth. Now what was he suppose to do? He couldn't tell him he was from a video game.. Maybe tell him that he had heard the name on some internet forum? Say he'd read about him online, or in the news?

"Um well. I'm Billy. Billy Kaplan. I sort of, um recognized you from.. the internet." He was going to fail at this so badly, and running away seemed like a great option at this point. "Heard about all that mess on the island.."