"Oh no," Hiccup intoned quietly, as he ran in and nearly skidded to a stop at Goliath's side. He didn't actually want to see this again, but at the same time, it just seemed wrong to not try to see if anything could be done to stop it.

Especially now that they knew what Punishment was this time.

"It's Punishment. They're going to get Punishment!"

Repeating what was already said and stating the obvious, yes, but he was in a slight panic at the thought of another member of the crew facing it again.